2012
- Brainless® on Cherries: Gold Medal, Fruit Beer – North American Brewers Association
- Wit Beer: Gold Medal, Belgian Style Wit Beer - LA International Beer Competition
- Imperial Stout: Gold Medal, Imperial Stout – North American Brewers Association
- Utah Sage Saison: Gold Medal, Herbed/Spiced or Pumpkin – North American Brewers Association
- Hop Syndrome Lager: Silver Medal, Session Beer - LA International Beer Competition
- Smoked & Oaked Belgian Style Strong Ale: Silver Medal, Experimental Beer - LA International Beer Competition
- Brainless® Belgian Style Golden Ale: Silver Medal, Belgian-Style Pale Strong Ale – North American Brewers Association
- Copper Cone Pale Ale: Silver Medal, Pale Ale – Denver International Beer Competition
- Double Skull Doppelbock: Silver Medal, Doppelbock – North American Brewers Association
- Hopulent IPA: Silver Medal, American Style IPA – Australian International Beer Festival
- Mid Mountain Mild Ale: 2nd Place, English Brown Ale - Great International Beer and Cider Competition
- Double Skull Doppelbock: 2nd Place, Strong Beer, Doublebock - Great International Beer and Cider Competition
- Brainless® Belgian Style Golden Ale: 2nd Place, Strong Beer, Mixed Styled - Great International Beer and Cider Competition
- Intermountain Wheat: Bronze Medal, American Style Wheat Beer - LA International Beer Competition
- Pfeifferhorn Lager: Bronze Medal, American Style Lager – Australian International Beer Festival
- Straight Up Saison: Bronze Medal, Saison – North American Brewers Association
- Capt’n Cromptons Pale Ale: Bronze Medal, American Style Pale Ale – Australian International Beer Festival
- Big Bad Baptist Imperial Stout: Bronze Medal, Specialty Beers – Denver International Beer Competition
- Utah Sage Saison: Bronze Medal, Herb and Spice Beer - Great American Beer Festival
- Brainless® on Peaches: Best of the Rockies/Southwest, Fruit Beer - United States Beer Tasting Championship
- Capt’n Cromptons Pale Ale: Best of the Rockies/Southwest, Bitter/ESB - United States Beer Tasting Championship
- Wit Beer: Best of the Rockies/Southwest, Wit Beer - United States Beer Tasting Championship
2011
- Wit Beer: Gold Medal, Wit – San Diego International Beer Festival
- Brainless® on Peaches: Silver Medal, Fruit Beer – Great American Beer Festival
- Pfeifferhorn Lager: Silver Medal, American Style Lager – San Diego International Beer Festival
- 825 State Stout: Bronze Medal, Packaged Stout – Australian International Beer Festival
- Hopulent IPA: Bronze Medal, Imperial IPA – European Beer Star
- Imperial IPA: Bronze Medal, Imperial IPA – Great American Beer Festival
- Imperial Red Ale: Bronze Medal, Packaged Ale – Australian International Beer Festival
- Intermountain Wheat: Bronze Medal, American Wheat – North American Brewers Association
- Rio’s Rompin’ Rye: Silver Medal, Rye Beer – North American Brewers Association
- Ratebeer.com Top 100 Breweries in the World (number 92)
2010
- Brainless® Belgian Style Golden Ale: Gold Medal, Belgian Strong Ale – North American Brewers Association
- Brainless® Belgian Style Golden Ale: Gold Medal, Belgian Strong Ale – San Diego International Beer Festival
- Galloway Porter: Silver Medal, Porter – 2010 Beer Fest Asia
- 825 State Stout: Bronze Medal, Oatmeal Stout – 2010 Great American Beer Festival
- Copper Cone Pale Ale: Bronze Medal, Pale Ale – 2010 San Diego International Beer Festival
- Intermountain Wheat: Bronze Medal, American Wheat Beer – North American Brewers Association
- Ratebeer.com Third Best New Brewery